4 Historic NYC Destinations to Add to Your Bucket List2. The Lyceum Theater There are actually two theaters that were completed in 1903 and are still in operation, but the New Amsterdam Theatre came in slightly after the Lyceum Theatre. Producer David Frohman had an apartment built atop 149 W. 45th Street in Manhattan, which allowed him to watch his wife, actress Margaret Illington, on stage with ease. Judy Holiday was also catapulted to fame at the Lyceum while playing Billie Dawn in Born Yesterday, the theaters longest-running show. Watch out for the next two historic destinations in NYC or head to www.aboutjodykriss.com to see the whole article.